Today will be a longish blogpost so please excuse if you do not want to read a long article.
While today is my birthday, I don’t feel at all like celebrating. When 8 million Kashmiris are locked down in Kashmir and 19 million to be sent in detention camp, the number may increase, how one one feel happy? Sadly, many people disregard that illegal immigration is everywhere. Whether it is UK or US, Indians too have illegally immigrated. If you look at the comments either in US or UK papers is just as toxic as you would find in twitter in India. Most of the people are uninformed of the various reasons that people choose to take a dangerous path to make home a new country. Alliances are also divided because the children grow up in another culture and then they will be ‘corrupted’ especially if women are sent back to India. The situation in India have never been as similar as they are today, see this from Najam Sethi, an internationally known left-leaning journalist
and similarly you can see how Indian and US Investigative journalism is having a slow death in both India and U.S.
There are good moments too as can be seen here –
We always say we are better than Pakistan but we seem to be going down to the same road and that can’t be good. Forget politics, even human right issues are not being tackled sensitively by our Supreme Court. Just today there came an incident involving one of the victims of the Muzaffarpur Shelter Home being allegedlly raped in a moving car. The case has been pending in the Supreme Court for quite sometime but no action being taken so far. Journalists either in Uttar Pradesh or Haryana are being booked for showing the truth. I have been trying to engage with people from across the political divide, i.e. the ones who support BJP. Majority of them are don’t have jobs and this is the only way they can get their frustration out. Also the dissonance in political message is such they feel that their jobs are being taken by outsiders. Ironically the Ministers get away with saying things like ‘North Indians lack qualifications’ . It shows lack of empathy on the Minister’s part. If they are citizens of the state, then it is the state’s responsibility of making sure they are skilled. If they are not skilled, then it is the Central Government and State Governments responsibility. Most of the States in the North are governed by BJP. I could share more but then it will all be about BJP only and nothing about the Chandrayaan 2 mission.
Chandrayaan 2 and Corporate Interests
Before we get to Chandrayaan 2, there are few interesting series I want to talk about, share about. The first one is AltBalaji’s Mission Over Mars which in some ways is similar to Mars 6-part series Docu-drama made by National Geographic and lot of movies, books etc. read over years. In both these and other books, movies etc. it has been shown how Corporate Interests win over science and exploration which the motives of such initiatives were and are. The rich become richer and richer while the poor become more poorer.
There has been also lot of media speculation that ISRO should be privatized similar to how NASA is and people saying that NASA’s importance has not lessened even though they couldn’t have been more wrong. Take the Space Launch System . It was first though of in the 2010 after the NASA Authorization Act of 2010 came into being. When it was shared or told it was told that it would be ready somewhere in 2016. Now it seems it won’t be ready until 2025. And who is responsible for this, the same company which has been responsible for lot of bad news in the international aviation business Boeing. The auditor’s report for NASA while blaming NASA for oversight also blames Boeing for not doing things right. And from what we have come to know that in the american system of self-regulation leaves much to be desired. More so, when an ex-employee of Boeing is exercising his fifth Amendment rights which raises the suspicion that there is more than just simply an oversight issue. Boeing also is a weapons manufacturer but that’s another story altogether. For people interested in the arms stuff, a wired article published 2 years back gives enough info. as to how America is good bad or Arms sale.
I know the whole thing gives a rather complex picture but that is the nature of things. The only thing I would say is we should be very careful in privatizing ISRO as the same issues are bound to happen sooner or later, the more private and non-transparent things become. We, the common citizens would never come to know if any sort of national or industrial espionage is happening and of course all profits would be of corporates while losses will be public as seen can be nowadays. Doesn’t leave a good taste in the mouth.
Now while the jury is still out as to what happened or might have happened and we hope that Vikram does connect within the 14 days there are lots of theories as to what could have gone wrong. While I’m no expert, I do find it hard to take the statement that probably ISRO saw an image of Chandrayaan 2 lander, at least not a single image has been released in the public. What ISRO has shared in its updates is that it located a lander which doesn’t tell much. While the Chandrayaan 2 orbitor started at 100 km. lunar orbit it probably would have some deviations to make sure that the orbiter itself doesn’t get into Moon’s gravity and crash-lands on the moon itself. The lens which probably would have been used would be to take panaromic shots and not telescopic in nature. As to what happened, we just don’t know as of yet. There are probably a dozen or two probabilities. One of the most simplest explanation to my mind could be some space rock could have crashed into the lander when it was landing. The dark side of the moon has more impacts than the one which we face so it’s entirely possible that the lander got hit by a space rock or lava. From what little I have been able to learn, the lander doesn’t seem to have any A.I. to manoeuver if such a scenario happens. Also any functioning A.I. would probably need more energy and for space missions energy, weight, electrical interference, contamination are all issues that Space Agencies have to deal with it. The other is of course, sensor failure, wrong calculation or a rough spot where it landed and broke the antennae. Till ISRO doesn’t share more details with us, we have only conjecture to help us.
Chandrayaan 2 Imaging
While we await news about the lander, would be curious to know about the images that Chandrayaan 2 is getting. Sadly, none of the images have made it to the public domain as of yet. Whether the images are in FITS or RAW format and whatever spectrum, (Chandrayaan 2 is going to image in a wide range of spectrum.) . Like Spirit and Opportunity did for NASA, I hope ISRO does show renderings of Moon as captured by the Orbitor, even though its lifeless so people, especially children get enthused about getting into Space Sciences .